If He Hits You Once...
Should You Leave?
Ever wondered why women stay
with men who hit them? Most violent men start out as loving
partners and the cycle of abuse begins insidiously. Here's how
to get out while you can Nicole
and Sean were totally in love. They'd been together since
they met at a mutual friend's party five months prior. “I
was attracted to Sean the moment I saw him,” Nicole
recalls. “He was cute and funny and we seemed to have
a lot in common. We both loved sports, eating out and going
to the movies. It wasn't long before we were discussing going
away on holiday together and I was thinking about moving in
with him.”
Then, one night, after they'd been out to a restaurant with
friends, something happened that made Nicole think maybe Sean
wasn't the guy she thought he was. “We'd had a really
good time, laughing and catching up with people I hadn't seen
for ages,” she says. “But I noticed that Sean
looked a bit dark every time I spoke to this guy I used to
work with. I didn't think much of it until Sean took me home.”
Once he was inside Nicole's flat, Sean lost it. “He
started shouting about how he couldn't believe I'd acted like
such a slut and then he slapped me. There was a big, red welt
across my cheek and I started to cry. He backed off immediately,
saying, 'I'm sorry, Nicole, I'm sorry.' He just looked so
guilt-stricken that I forgave him.”
Joanna can relate to Nicole's story. When she first met Steven
– a handsome and gregarious mechanic – she was
totally smitten. “You could say he was an angel,”
she says. “We got on really well and I fell in love
with him.” But only weeks into their relationship, Steven's
behaviour started to change. “He was drinking a lot
and I found out that he was taking speed. If I went out with
my friends, he'd get jealous and angry. Even then, though,
I didn't think he'd hit me.” But one night, after Joanna
came home from the movies, Steven dragged her across the floor
by her hair and punched her in the face until she was bleeding.
“I could hardly move and I was so terrified,”
she says. “But he made me have a shower and clean myself
up. Then we went away for three weeks so no one would see
what he'd done to me.”
Considering the circumstances, should Nicole and Joanna have
packed their bags and left straight away? Absolutely, advises
Dr Janet Hall, a psychologist specialising in sex therapy
and relationship issues. “If he hits you once, run for
the hills.”
Dennise Simpson, manager of the ACT Domestic Violence Crisis
Service, says that if it was her daughter, she'd advise her
to leave the relationship too. Why? “While there are
odd cases where it may be a one-off incident, I'd be very
concerned the violence will be ongoing or intermittent.”
Welfare worker Val Player, who's counselled dozens of domestic
violence victims, agrees. “Most often, the situation
never gets better,” she says.
The similarities between the girl's relationships don't end
there. In both cases the men were extremely sorry about what
they'd done – until it happened again – which
is common with domestic violence. Nicole says during the three
months after he hit her, Sean behaved like the perfect boyfriend.
“He got along well with my mum and dad and all my friends
thought he was great,” she says. Then, one afternoon,
after Sean had been at a friend's place watching football,
he turned up at Nicole's flat in a rage. “He was drunk
and started going off about how he couldn't trust me when
I was out of his sight. I told him he was wrong and that I
loved him, but he wouldn't listen.” Then Sean hit Nicole
again.
“This time I got angry and told him never to do that
again,” Nicole remembers. “He went all quiet and
started crying. I was in a real quandary about whether I should
keep seeing him or tell him it was over. After all, it wasn't
like he'd beaten me and I suppose I thought he had slapped
me like that because he loved me so much.”
Joanna says a cycle of violence set in with her and Steven;
he'd get high, hit her and then feel guilty. “We'd have
make-up sex and everything would be good for a while,”
she says. “Then he'd start drinking again or taking
drugs. I had bruises every morning – but he was always
so sorry and I was stupid enough to believe him.”
So why didn't they just leave? Simpson says women respond
differently according to their circumstances. “Some
women hope, or want to believe, that he won't do it again,”
she explains, or sincerely think he won't. You have to remember,
a lot of young women have chosen this person and been chosen
by this person to commit themselves to a relationship, even
if it has only been for a few months. They really want to
believe that he's the same person he was when they first met,
and that the relationship will work out in the long run. It
can be a great shock when a man with non-violent tendancies
suddenly uses physical abuse against you. And it can be very
persuasive having the guy you love sitting there saying, 'I
love you. I don't know how this happened. It will never happen
again.' Or worse, threatening that if you do leave him, he
may end his life, which is a common response for men.”
Nicole and Joanna's situation is typical of how a cycle of
domestic violence starts – with a push, a slap, or yelling.
“It can follow a drinking or drug binge, but these don't
cause domestic violence. They just give a guy with unexpressed
anger or low-coping skills an excuse for his aggression,”
says Player.
This build-up phase quickly develops into other forms of
abuse, which can include more physical violence. But your
boyfriend doesn't have to hit you for it to be domestic abuse,
says domestic violence refuge worker Louise Chambers. He might
start telling you that you spend too much money on clothes
or make-up, or that he thinks you see your friends to often.
Soon he's controlling your budget and your schedule. He may
force you to watch porn or have sex against your will. Or
maybe he's slipping in comments about how you're getting too
fat, or how you're not clever enough to get that job you want.
As a result, you become submissive, says Chambers. You're
afraid of what might happen if you don't surrender. And that's
his aim: to make you so powerless you'll never leave him –
because he couldn't live without you and he's not going to
let you live without him. Simpson says a common tactic used
by men with this aim is to say he's sorry, but then make the
woman take responsibility for his actions. “He'll say,
'I'm sorry I hit you, but if you hadn't said that, done this
, or acted like that, this wouldn't have happened.' He makes
her feel like she caused it or deserved to be hit and then
she blames herself.”
According to the Australian Institute of Crimimology, an
average of 125 females of all ages are murdered each year
in Australia, with women aged between 21 and 23 at the greatest
risk. The likelihood of a woman being killed by a male stranger
is very slight, in fact each year in Australia fewer than
14 women are killed by a man they don't know. Nearly three
in five of all femicides (killing of women aged 15 years and
over) occur between intimate partners and nearly all of these
are the result of domestic altercation. And when a woman is
killed, it will most likely take place in a private residence.
But here's the good news: recognising domestic violence for
what it is means you're halfway to preventing yourself from
becoming a statistic. Start by realising that there is no
typical victim – you can be from any social class, age
group or culture – and that you're not alone. In 1996,
The Women's Safety Survey, conducted by the Australian Bureau
of Statistics, estimated that 2.6 million women, or 38 per
cent of the adult female population had experienced one or
more incidents of physical or sexual violence since the age
of 15. For the majority (2.5 million women), the violence
was perpetrated by a man.
Getting the help you need and protecting yourself against
violence, or escaping the relationship, are the other factors
in preventing yourself from becoming another statistic. Nicole
admits it was really difficult, but that she eventually broke
it off with Sean. “I made sure I did it in a public
place and that a friend was waiting for me when I got home,”
she explains. “Sean did try to get in touch with me
a couple of times, but I didn't return his calls. I moved
into another flat so he didn't have my address anymore –
I was really worried that he'd get more violent with me.”
There is no denying that leaving any relationship is hard,
says the Domestic Violence Advocacy Service (DVAS). In violent
situations, women have to negotiate a number of obstacles
that can make leaving difficult, or even dangerous. But if
you think with your heart, not your head, you're in danger.
For Joanna, leaving almost wasn't an option. In the worst
episode of violence she experienced, Joanna recalls lying
on the floor while Steven kicked her and then smashed her
in the face. “That night I was agony. I couldn't breath.
I thought I was dying. I said to myself, 'God, please give
me strength to leave because if I don't, he's going to kill
me.'” Joanna waited fearfully until her boyfriend left
the house, then took a taxi to the local police station, where
she lost consciousness. When police officers called an ambulance
Joanna had six broken ribs, a broken nose and her 45-kilogram
body was covered in blood and bruises. Five days later, after
being visited in hospital by a social worker, she was ready
to take out a restraining order against Steven, to make a
full statement to the police about the months of abuse she
had endured and to try and begin her life again.
Simpson says this is the very reason her organisation doesn't
blatantly tell women to leave. “It can be very difficult
not to tell her to go, especially if we're concerned about
her safety. But telling a woman what she should and shouldn't
do runs the risk of alienating her further down the track,”
she explains. “For example, if we advise her to leave
and she doesn't, then six months later he hurts her badly,
she'll be reluctant to seek our support because she didn't
take our advice before. We have to work with women from the
stage which they are at – she might not be ready to
leave, she may be too scared, or she may say that she loves
him so much she doesn't want to leave. Instead, we ask about
other aspects of their relationship, to ascertain how safe
she feels with him on a day-to-day basis – so she realises
for herself that perhaps it isn't as positive as she thought.
A typical scenario is a woman calling up and saying, 'My relationship
is great, but my boyfriend hit me. I don't know whether it's
just a one-off, or if he'll do it again?'”
“Through questioning,” Simpson continues, “she
may also discover that he doesn't like her going out with
her girlfriends. Or that he doesn't like her family, or her
spending time with them. She may also realise that he gets
drunk and puts her down sometimes. Hopefully, this puts things
into perspective for her.”
Hall suggests writing down all the pros and cons to staying
or leaving the relationship. “Tell another objective,
trustworthy adult what's going on and ask as many people as
you can whether you should stay or leave. Or approach one
of the many professional sevices that offer help, such as
your community legal or health centre,” she says. |